Beyond Short Snippets Deep Networks for Video Classification

Posted by Software Engineers George Toderici and Sudheendra Vijayanarasimhan

Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs) have recently shown rapid progress in advancing the state of the art of detecting and classifying objects in static images, automatically learning complex features in pictures without the need for manually annotated features. But what if one wanted not only to identify objects in static images, but also analyze what a video is about? After all, a video isn’t much more than a string of static images linked together in time.

As it turns out, video analysis provides even more information to the object detection and recognition task performed by CNN’s by adding a temporal component through which motion and other information can be also be used to improve classification. However, analyzing entire videos is challenging from a modeling perspective because one must model variable length videos with a fixed number of parameters. Not to mention that modeling variable length videos is computationally very intensive.

In Beyond Short Snippets: Deep Networks for Video Classification, to be presented at the 2015 Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition conference (CVPR 2015), we¹ evaluated two approaches - feature pooling networks and recurrent neural networks (RNNs) - capable of modeling variable length videos with a fixed number of parameters while maintaining a low computational footprint. In doing so, we were able to not only show that learning a high level global description of the video’s temporal evolution is very important for accurate video classification, but that our best networks exhibited significant performance improvements over previously published results on the Sports 1 million dataset (Sports-1M).

In previous work, we employed 3D-convolutions (meaning convolutions over time and space) over short video clips - typically just a few seconds - to learn motion features from raw frames implicitly and then aggregate predictions at the video level. For purposes of video classification, the low level motion features were only marginally outperforming models in which no motion was modeled.

To understand why, consider the following two images which are very similar visually but obtain drastically different scores from a CNN model trained on static images:

Slight differences in object poses/context can change the predicted class/confidence of CNNs trained on static images.

Since each individual video frame forms only a small part of the video’s story, static frames and short video snippets (2-3 secs) use incomplete information and could easily confuse subtle fine-grained distinctions between classes (e.g: Tae Kwon Do vs. Systema) or use portions of the video irrelevant to the action of interest.

To get around this frame-by-frame confusion, we used feature pooling networks that independently process each frame and then pool/aggregate the frame-level features over the entire video at various stages. Another approach we took was to utilize an RNN (derived from Long Short Term Memory units) instead of feature pooling, allowing the network itself to decide which parts of the video are important for classification. By sharing parameters through time, both feature pooling and RNN architectures are able to maintain a constant number of parameters while capturing a global description of the video’s temporal evolution.

In order to feed the two aggregation approaches, we compute an image “pixel-based” CNN model, based on the raw pixels in the frames of a video. We processed videos for the “pixel-based” CNNs at one frame per second to reduce computational complexity. Of course, at this frame rate implicit motion information is lost.

To compensate, we incorporate explicit motion information in the form of optical flow - the apparent motion of objects across a cameras viewfinder due to the motion of the objects or the motion of the camera. We compute optical flow images over adjacent frames to learn an additional “optical flow” CNN model.

Left: Image used for the pixel-based CNN; Right: Dense optical flow image used for optical flow CNN

The pixel-based and optical flow based CNN model outputs are provided as inputs to both the RNN and pooling approaches described earlier. These two approaches then separately aggregate the frame-level predictions from each CNN model input, and average the results. This allows our video-level prediction to take advantage of both image information and motion information to accurately label videos of similar activities even when the visual content of those videos varies greatly.

Badminton (top 25 videos according to the max-pooling model). Our methods accurately label all 25 videos as badminton despite the variety of scenes in the various videos because they use the entire video’s context for prediction.

We conclude by observing that although very different in concept, the max-pooling and the recurrent neural network methods perform similarly when using both images and optical flow. Currently, these two architectures are the top performers on the Sports-1M dataset. The main difference between the two was that the RNN approach was more robust when using optical flow alone on this dataset. Check out a short video showing some example outputs from the deep convolutional networks presented in our paper.

---

1 Research carried out in collaboration with University of Maryland, College Park PhD student Joe Yue-Hei Ng and University of Texas at Austin PhD student Matthew Hausknecht, as part of a Google Software Engineering Internship^?

Related Post:

computer

• Take a better selfie with Lily
• Free Lecture The Psychology of Computer Insecurity
• MOOC Research and Innovation
• Calculating Ada The Countess of Computing
• When can Quantum Annealing win
• Creating a templated Binary Search Tree Class in C
• Projecting without a projector sharing your smartphone content onto an arbitrary display
• Will a robot take your job
• Facebook Introduces ‘Hack ’ the programming language of the future
• High Resolution Scary Haunted House Wallpapers for Desktop
• TYBSC IT Sem V Question Papers 2009 Mumbai University
• Home automation update
• Very easy to download youtube videos audio mp3 format
• HD Dark Desktop Background Wallpapers Download
• Launching the Quantum Artificial Intelligence Lab
• Syrias children learn to code with the Raspberry Pi
• Running omxplayer from the command line easily using alias
• Largest collection of Google Logos on the web Set 7
• Collection of SQL queries with Answer and Output Set 2
• Prevent access to specific partition or drive
• Summer Games Learn to Program
• PiAUISuite Update and Voicecommand v3 1
• Sign in to edx org with Google and Facebook and
• Large Scale Machine Learning for Drug Discovery
• Hacker Tricks from Insiders A Threat to ERP Systems

beyond

• The Internet Is Failing The Website Preservation Test
• Remembering to forget
• Beyond Touch using everyday tools as input devices

classification